Oliver M. Lee, W. W. Cox's brother-in-law, received the attention of those who were talking and guessing about who might have planned the killing of Pat Garrett. Similarly, Lee had some reason for having considerably less than kindly feeling toward Garrett.

The trouble was with something that had occurred in back in February, 1896. The flamboyant lawyer, Albert Jennings Fountain, a compulsive hounder of all whom he believed to be lawbreakers, along with his little boy Henry, had mysteriously vanished from the face of the earth as they were driving along a lonely stretch of road beside the White Sands. The disappearance--unquestionably a murder--had occurred immediately after he had presented a grand jury with evidence he had gathered, and secured an indictment against Oliver Lee, charged with rustling and brand-burning. These charges were later dismissed but Lee soon faced a more serious charge--he was accused of the murder of Albert and Henry Fountain.

In the two years that followed, Lee was not taken into custody, although a $10,000 reward was offered for the arrest and conviction of those responsible for the murder of Fountain and his son. Then, on April 12, 1898, Sheriff Pat Garrett made an affidavit implicating Oliver Lee and his alleged accomplices, Bill McNew and Jim Gililland, and secured a bench warrant for their arrest. Just before dawn on July 13, Garrett and a posse surrounded Lee's ranch house at Wildey's Well. It had been a warm night and Lee and Gililland were sleeping on the flat roof of the ranch house.

In the ensuing gunfight, Kearney was mortally wounded and the attackers withdrew. By some miracle of chance, both Lee and Gililland were unscathed. Neither sought revenge in the years that followed. Why then should a man like Oliver Lee, if he had score to settle, have waited almost nine years to do something about it? The only answer--a very weak one--is that in 1907, supposedly Garrett was looking for evidence that would again charge Lee with the killing of the Fountains. True, the reward offered for their slayers had never been officially withdrawn, but it was well known that usually an acquitted person could not be tried again on the same charge - Lee had been tried and declared innocent in June, 1899.

Uploaded on 07.28.2014 by El Paso Museum of History

Out of Area / Out of Area, (1880 - 1889), Conflict

  • Oliver Lee
  • pat garrett

Your comment will be visible after the El Paso Museum staff has reviewed it. This usually happens within 24 hours.

Thank you for your comment

Oliver M. Lee

Report this entry

Choose the most important reason for this report

Your name

Your email address

Optional detail

Thank you for your report

More from the same community-collection

2230 First Ave

2230 First Ave post renovation 2015ish Fluff & Barbara

Home 1965

2230 First Ave Atlanta Ga before renavation (Fluff)



Muslim Brothers

Sheik Ruradeen of Gallup NM & McCarthy of ICEP

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters meeting MACHETE

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG Ghostbusters

El Paso YOUNG Ghostbusters Albuquerque Comic Con

El Paso YOUNG Ghostbusters

The El Paso YOUNG Ghostbusters In Albuquerque Comic Con

Map of Southwestern United States Natural Gas Pipe Lines

This map illustrates natural gas pipelines extending from California, Arizona, New Mexico, Texas, and Louisiana. The legend lists pipeline names...

Map of Texas and the Countries Adjacent

This map of Texas and its adjacent countries was compiled for the state department and includes listed land, area, and...

Map of the Rio Grande El Paso-Juarez Valley circa 1930

This map illustrates the river path between El Paso, Texas and Juarez, Mexico. The location of the International Dam, Riverside...

Native Tribes of North America

This University of California map from series number 13 regionally locates and names North American Native Tribes. Tribal names and...